SAP ECC vs. SAP S/4HANA – Which One is Right for You? (2024)

Let’s take a deep dive into SAP’s core offering of products so you can understand the nuances between them. It will help you better develop and refine your SAP roadmap.

We receive many questions about the differences between SAP’s core offerings so it’s important to define the various SAP products to make sure there’s no confusion.

For those with a non-technical SAP background, here’s what you should know about the differences between SAP ECC, SAP HANA, and SAP S/4HANA.

What is SAP ECC?

SAP ECC stands for SAP ERP Central Component. It’s also known as SAP ERP. It’s one of SAP legacy applications that originally designed to operate on a third-party database such as Oracle and IBM DB2.

SAP ECC is the system that most companies have and are familiar with because it includes the more commonly used modules such as financials, human resources (HR), warehousing, and logistics. SAP ECC also has modules such as Production Planning, Materials Management, and Plant Maintenance for manufacturers.

SAP ECC is the core product within SAP Business Suite and should not be confused with SAP Business Suite. SAP Business Suite goes beyond the foundational modules and supports specialized or complex functions such as supply chain management (SCM) and customer relationship management (CRM). Similar to SAP ECC, SAP Business Suite can run on a third-party database such as MSSQL, IBM DB2, and SAP HANA.

What About SAP R/3?

SAP R/3 is SAP ECC’s predecessor and some companies still run R/3. At its core, R/3 uses a client-server model to store, retrieve, analyze, and process data while SAP ECC runs on a web-based application server. Users can now access ERP data through web browsers as well as clients (SAP GUI).

SAP ECC began as a financial software package called RF in 1973, followed by a Material Management module called RM/1. As SAP added additional components, the package was renamed to R1. In 1979, R2 was released to integrate accounting, manufacturing, supply chain logistics, and HR. In 1992, R/3 was released to support various operating systems and databases. In 2004, SAP renamed it to SAP ECC. SAP ERP and ECC are now used interchangeably.

What is SAP HANA?

SAP HANA is an in-memory columnar database designed to accelerate SAP apps and business processes that was released in 2010. SAP HANA is now the foundation for running SAP Business Suite products. It’s an in-memory, column-oriented database. It simplified the data structure and improved performance to increase user productivity, provide real-time visibility, and take advantage of analytics. It was created so companies can react to up-to-the-minute data instead of static quarterly reports.

What is SAP Business Suite on HANA?

SAP Business Suite on HANA is SAP ECC that operates on the SAP HANA database. If you are running SAP Business Suite on a third-party database, you can move it to SAP HANA. When you put SAP Business Suite on HANA, you improve performance without having to make changes to the app layer. SAP Business Suite performs faster on SAP HANA because it’s working inside the memory component. The ECC functionality within SAP Business Suite remains the same.

What is the Difference Between SAP ECC vs. SAP HANA?

SAP ECC is the ERP system and SAP HANA is the in-memory database, designed to handle transactions and analytics. HANA was originally designed to be a data warehouse, but it has grown into all-in-one data platform that manages analytical, transactional, and application development.

SAP plans on terminating its maintenance support for SAP ECC in 2027 so SAP customers will be required to move to S/4HANA. For most companies, it’s an expensive and lengthy undertaking, often spanning years.

What is SAP S/4HANA?

After R/3, SAP S/4HANA is the fourth version of SAP Business Suite.

SAP rebuilt SAP ECC from the ground up to create SAP S/4HANA in 2015 to take advantage of SAP HANA’s performance and data analytics capabilities. That is a big benefit and a big drawback. S/4HANA can exclusively run on SAP HANA while SAP ECC can run on a third-party database.

S/4HANA is designed to solve complex problems and manage larger amounts of data than ECC and R/3. It provides a better user experience with SAP Fiori and makes a shift from transactional systems that record data to real-time data from internal and external sources.

Why are some companies reluctant to move to S/4HANA? Some companies will have to completely overhaul their existing business processes.

SAP S/4HANA Finance has become a stepping stone for this transition because S/4HANA Finance allows users to move accounting and finance processes to S/4HANA while keep using SAP ECC or other SAP products.

What’s the Difference Between SAP HANA vs. SAP S/4HANA?

It’s simple. SAP S/4HANA is the ERP system like SAP ECC while SAP HANA is the database.

What’s the Right SAP Offering for You?

It’s important to understand the differences between SAP product portfolio so you can map out your SAP roadmap. By understanding the benefits and challenges of each SAP offering, you’ll be able to make informed decisions that ensure their SAP systems and business requirements are aligned.

To learn more about how you can get more value from your SAP systems, visit our resources page where we have SAP whitepapers, webinars, data sheets, and much more. Or you can contact us today to find out how we can help you maximize your SAP investment.

SAP ECC vs. SAP S/4HANA – Which One is Right for You? (2024)

FAQs

Which is better SAP ECC or SAP HANA? ›

SAP S/4HANA has a simplified model that makes use of a universal journal. ECC on the other has additional indexes and aggregate tables. S/4HANA offers more streamlined integration with other SAP solutions, such as SAP SuccessFactors, Ariba, and Concur.

What is the difference between SAP ECC and S 4HANA? ›

Differences between SAP ECC vs S/4HANA

Database: ECC supports databases from other providers such as Db2, Oracle, or Informix, however, S/4HANA only runs on SAP HANA. As a result, S/4HANA has much faster reaction times thanks to its in-memory database.

What is the advantage of S 4HANA over ECC? ›

Advantages of SAP S/4HANA

These capabilities help businesses improve their speed, productivity, and efficiency. Here are the advantages of S/4HANA over ECC: Real-time data analysis: SAP S/4HANA lets you analyze large amounts of data in real-time. Working with large data sets from one interface helps you save time.

What are key reasons for preferring a new implementation of SAP S 4HANA rather than a system conversion from SAP ERP? ›

SAP S/4HANA implementations provide a comprehensive solution for large enterprises. With SAP S/4HANA, a company's ERP, CRM, SRM, SCM, PLM, and HCM solutions are all integrated into a single platform. Full access to the entire SAP Business Suite through a single platform greatly streamlines business processes.

Which SAP system is best? ›

Top 5 highest paying SAP modules
  1. SAP S/4HANA (High-Performance Analytic Appliance) ...
  2. SAP ECC FI (Financial Accounting) ...
  3. SAP SCM (Supply Chain Management) ...
  4. SAP HCM (Human Capital Management) ...
  5. SAP BI (Business Intelligence)

Is SAP ECC outdated? ›

The support for SAP Business Suite 7, which includes SAP ECC 6, will cease in 2027. This presents a challenge for IT teams who have spent years perfecting their ECC abilities and modifying their systems to precisely meet their business objectives.

What are the main benefits of S 4HANA? ›

S/4 HANA applications leverage speed, context and data accessibility like never before. Improved performance and speed: S/4HANA enables improved performance by allowing you to plan, execute, generate reports and analytics based on live data, as well as triggering period closing and providing improved predictions.

What are the key benefits of SAP S 4HANA? ›

Overview of SAP S/4HANA Benefits
  • Boost Your Performance. With its underlying SAP HANA database technology, SAP's newest ERP platform enables real-time data insights and an overall faster access to your entire data volume. ...
  • Simplify Your Processes. ...
  • Improve Your User Experience. ...
  • Innovate Your Business.

What is the disadvantage of SAP S4 Hana? ›

Here are some commonly expressed S/4HANA drawbacks: While S/4HANA's financials and logistics are the most mature, some of the functionality is not as mature as that of SAP ECC. Implementation is complex, time-consuming and expensive. S/4HANA can only run on the SAP HANA database.

Which SAP is replaced by SAP's 4HANA? ›

Most S/4HANA customers will replace existing SAP ECC systems, but a migration to S/4HANA is different from a standard version upgrade.

What are the three guiding principles of SAP S 4HANA? ›

Integration, Innovation, Agility & Speed – the three key principles of SAP Intelligent Enterprise
  • Integration.
  • Innovation.
  • Agility & Speed.
Jul 9, 2020

Can SAP ECC run on HANA? ›

The main difference between these two systems is that SAP ECC can run on Oracle, whereas S/4HANA can only run on HANA. Because of this, some companies will probably have to alter the way they do business. Some companies have used S/4HANA Finance as a stepping stone in this transition.

Why is SAP HANA better? ›

Unparalleled Speed

Because SAP HANA stores and pulls data from RAM rather than hard storage, it can resolve queries in under one second, even in large-scale applications. This allows for a vastly superior user experience, facilitating the virtualization of real-time data, all at the drop of a hat.

What are the advantages of ECC in SAP? ›

SAP ECC is also used by businesses to improve customer service, warehouse management, and quality control. It provides end-to-end data integrations between various business processes, enables real-time data processing, and offers real-time data insights.

Which cloud is better for SAP? ›

Azure provides best-in-class infrastructure and SAP provides end-to-end managed services for in-memory applications, database and platform. You'll see the broadest choice and industry-leading performance when running your SAP workloads on Azure.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Arielle Torp

Last Updated:

Views: 6546

Rating: 4 / 5 (61 voted)

Reviews: 84% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Arielle Torp

Birthday: 1997-09-20

Address: 87313 Erdman Vista, North Dustinborough, WA 37563

Phone: +97216742823598

Job: Central Technology Officer

Hobby: Taekwondo, Macrame, Foreign language learning, Kite flying, Cooking, Skiing, Computer programming

Introduction: My name is Arielle Torp, I am a comfortable, kind, zealous, lovely, jolly, colorful, adventurous person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.