European vs American food safety standards (2024)

Get your HACCP in
1 hour!

European vs American food safety standards (1)

Food Safety System in 15 min

European vs American food safety standards (2)

Setting up a food business

You must know the food safety standards that are acceptable to your local authority. Food quality is the quality characteristics of food that are acceptable to consumers. You need to consider some prerequisites before setting up a food business. Selection of right premises holds the necessary food regulations & allows you to prepare food safely. The law is complex, and most acts and regulations affecting the food industry are difficult to interpret. However, unawareness or ignorance of the law is no justification in the event of prosecution.

The European Commission established an integrated approach to food safety 'from farm to fork'. The European versus US Food standards & law systems use different vocabulary, and we need to understand the structure of the food quality & safety standards first.

The American food standards are examined by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA)of the United States Department of Health and Human Services (HHS), and the Food Safety Inspection Service (FSIS) of the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA). While the FSIS is accountable for examining poultry, egg, and meat products under the Meat and Poultry and Egg Inspection Act and for certifying organic products, the “FDA is responsible for almost all the remaining food supply.

Whereas the food safety system in Europe is comprised of 27 member countries, and each generally developed a distinct food safety system. EU food safety legislation is more focused on food processing than farmers, who are greatly impacted by laws related to the management of animals, the usage of veterinary medicines and pesticides, and the enforcement of agricultural plans. The General Food Law Regulation in the Eu guarantees the highest level of protection of human life and consumers' interests regarding food while ensuring the current functioning of the internal market.

Everyone involved in the food business, from farm to fork, shares equal responsibility to follow the food safety standards. The government plays a vital role in creating standards and administering their enforcement. Secondary roles are to be followed by trade and consumer organizations that inform policy, professional organizations, and academic institutions engrossed in research and education. Food safety involves the control measures and conditions necessary to control hazards and to protect consumers' health from any harm injury, or, illness. Those working with food can avoid food poisoning and other illnesses by practicing the four C's of food safety – cross-contamination control, cleaning, cooking, and chilling.

What are food safety standards?

Food safety standards are a set of principles that a food must meet if it is to be appropriate for human consumption, such as food source from where it is purchased, color, permissible additives, freshness, composition, and total bacterial count.

Food quality is a vital key to the success of food products with regard to a food business to remain competitive in the global food market. It signifies all the traits and parameters of food items are acceptable to the consumer. The food quality parameters include external factors such as appearance, color, size, shape, gloss, texture, flavor, and consistency. The perception of product quality is not so abrupt and obvious.

Although not commonly accepted, the definition for quality with greater unanimity is "suitability for the consumer usage."

In 2019, the EU reviewed its General Food Law Regulationintending to increase the transparency of the Europe risk assessment in the food chain, strengthening the reliability, objectivity, and independence of the studies used by EFSA. The new provisions have applied from March 27, 2021.

European vs American food safety standards (3)


Food safety systems in the US and Europe

EU laws are harmonized by the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA), while the U.S. food processing sector is broadly regulated by state and federal agencies USDA FSIS. Food and drug administration responsibilities include measures to protect “the public health by assuring that food are wholesome, safe, sanitary and labeled properly while European food regulations cover the risk assessment, conducted by the EFSA, and risk management, conducted by the European Commission. One of the main dissimilarities between the US and EU food safety systems is the federal and centralized character of the United States versus the non-federal organization of Europe. At the same time, the implementation of food-related laws and enforcement in the U.S. is concentrated on a federal level.

What types of food safety standards are used in food production?

Food must be kept safe and of good quality in the supply chain for national and international trade. There are multiple food safety standards used in food production: International public standards (such as Codex Alimentarius), the foreign (importing) retailer's standards, internationally recognized food safety standards, the importer's public standards, which may vary from country to country, domestic retailers standards, and domestic public standards.

The food safety laws and regulationsare implemented by food authorities and enforced by law and are usually developed and published under the umbrellas of national & local standards bodies. The developed countries should adopt the regulations for many types of food. However, differences in the quality standards do exist. It is because of variances in the background where the food is grown, climatic conditions, different food habits, and dissimilarity of raw material.

In Europe, the EFSA evaluates the safety of regulated food ingredients such as additives, enzymes, flavoring ingredients, and nutritional substances, intending to support risk managers in authorizing their use in foods. For example, EFSA has evaluated thousands of flavorings used in foods by 2020. Access to an adequate amount of safe and nutritious food is key to sustaining life and promoting good health. Unsafe food containing harmful microorganisms, viruses, parasites, or chemical residues can cause more than 200 diseases ranging from diarrhea to cancers.

Why do restaurants follow food safety regulations?

Your business reputation hinges on your customer's trust in the food premises to serve safer quality food. If word gets out that your egg salad sandwich, sushi, oysters, or steamed mussels caused food poisoning, you’ll not only lose customers and your reputation but may lose your food permit, fines and legal implications may occur.

Food safety standards help hotels, restaurants, catering companies, cafés, stores, canteens, and airlines to prepare and serve food safely so that customers don’t become sick. It is a moral, legal, and commercial obligation to provide safe food to the customers. It is by law for the restaurants to follow food safety regulations to make sure that they’re serving safe, quality food. Chicken that will be served undercooked or not properly defrosted, products made from raw eggs such as mayonnaise and mousse, shellfish, wild mushrooms, and fish must be sourced from approved or reputable suppliers or vendors.

To run a successful food business, it must comply with the food safety law that will result in satisfied customers, brand protection, less food wastage, higher staff morale, and promotes increased productivity.

Precautions must be taken to avoid the cross contaminations issues, for this raw food must be kept apart from high-risk food. It is recommended that separate clearly labeled units be used. A supervisor or manager is responsible for the overall process, including receiving the raw product, temperature monitoring, pest control, and personal hygiene competency under the requirements of HACCP.

Supervisors have a key role in the successful implementation of HACCP and the promotion of positive food safety culture. Food safety awareness and induction training depend upon the level and understanding of personnel to be conducted and the laws to be implemented. High standards of personal hygiene are essential to prevent the contamination of food by food handlers. Many organizations have developed their quality assurance systems and may comply with the ISO 9000 series. More than 20 systems for quality assurance, food safety, retail trade systems, and certification systems are used in Europe. These standards have been developed by the industry to inflict standards on a great variety of food products. However, although food safety standards cover about 80% of the food production in Europe, consumers may still find it difficult to choose the right product, as standards differ in transparency, action, documentation, and control. Quality must be built into a food product – it cannot be inspected into it.

COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS BETWEEN EU VS AMERICAN FOOD SAFETY STANDARDS

The great concern lies with consumers, who must be aware of the level of safety associated with the foods they buy. The main difference between the US and Europe is that Europeans do not let known or suspected carcinogens (cancer-causing agents) in their food. In contrast, the common use of Potassium Bromate KBrO3 (added to flour to make the dough rise higher and turn stark white) and Azodicarbonamide, or ADA (a whitening agent for cereal flour), are common in the United States, and not allowed in EU for human consumption. To understand the differences between European vs Americanfood standards, the assembly of each system needs to be taken into consideration.

AmericaEurope
Food RegulationsThe food regulations in America is carried out by four major agencies: the Food and Drug Administration (FDA), which is part of the Department of Health and Human Services (DHHS), the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), the Food Safety and Inspection Service (FSIS) of the US Department of Agriculture (USDA); and the National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS) of the Department of Commerce.In Europe, the central government has been given the charge for protecting public health and ensuring food hygiene and safety legislation to local authorities.
Labeling AllergensIn the US the Food Allergen Labeling and Consumer Protection Act (FALCPA) governs allergen labeling requirements for all FDA-regulated consumer-packaged foods but does not cover poultry, most meats, certain egg products, or most alcoholic beverages.The European regulations require food businesses to provide written oral information about allergenic ingredients for non packaged food such as retailers, restaurants, takeaways, bakeries, etc.
Common AllergensAccording to FDA policies, food packaging must disclose the presence of the following common allergens: milk, egg, fish, shellfish, tree nuts, wheat, peanuts, and soybeans.EU FIC guidelines require the compulsory listing of 14 common allergens.
Use of Chemical preservatives: What's the difference?Chlorine for washing chicken: American slaughterhouses wash chicken carcasses with chlorine after slaughter to kill any bacteria left on the skin in their production process.Stop chemical contamination:
TheEU considers that depending on chlorine rinse at the end of the meat production,thiscould be a way of compensating for poor hygiene standards - such as crowded & dirty abattoirs.In comparison, the UK does not allow this practice to keep the meat as clean as possible throughout the processing without counting on decontamination & the use of chlorine.
Growth hormones are the new norm: The US uses growth hormones in animal feed to accelerate growth and boost up production.Say no to chemical pesticides on food: Pesticide residues are a common concern for European citizens. The EC urges to use the integrated pest management & other approaches such as non-chemical ones.
Use of chemical preservatives in the US: A loaf of bread in the US contains a minimal amount of potassium bromate, and FDA labels it generally recognized as safe (GRAS).According to the EU food safety regulations, the use of KBrO3 and azodicarbonamide are banned to be used as dough conditioners for bread making. Limits are set on the expectations that it is carcinogenic to humans.
GMO TECHNOLOGYThe GMO predominantly plants, have been commercially grown in some countries, especially the Americas, since the mid-1990s.GMO plants are not yet permitted in Europe.
USE OF ADDITIVES IN FOODAdditives in US: Additives are referenced on ingredient labels by their full names in the US.Additives in Europe marked as E-Number: The food additives must be authorized, and under European legislation, the EFSA assesses the substance and its intended use and after the approval, a 3 to 4 digit code is assigned as the E Number for the additives.

Which countries have the highest food safety standards?

Numerous studies have been conducted into ranking the food standards of different countries, taking into account not only food safety but also food quality, affordability, and availability. A study conducted by the Global Food Security Index (GFSI) enlist the following 10 countries to have the top overall scores for affordability, availability, quality, and safety.

  • Singapore
  • Ireland
  • United States
  • United Kingdom
  • Netherlands
  • Australia
  • Switzerland
  • Finland
  • Canada
  • France

Food safety laws are regulated at the federal level in most countries because state and local government levels and systems are quite complicated and fragmented. As an outcome, the requirements for working and owning a food business usually vary state by state. The food laws will prohibit the import and export of adulterated food products that have deluded the general food laws in any context. Thus the proper implementation of food laws encourages fair trade practices through compliance. It also helps in the development of the food industry because quality control along sound scientific lines tends to promote better consumer acceptance of foods.

References: https://ec.europa.eu/food/horizontal-topics/general-food-law/transparency-and-sustainability-eu-risk-assessment-food-chain_en

Global food security index 2019 report

http://www.foodshap.com/blog/author/admin/

ISAAA (2018) Global status of commercialized biotech/GM crops: 2018. http://www.isaaa.org/resources/publications/briefs/54/default.asp. Accessed 26 Nov 2019


European vs American food safety standards (5)

Food safety

European vs American food safety standards (2024)

FAQs

Is European food safer than American? ›

Europeans maintain higher food safety regulations.

Combined, these strict food regulations protect against possible, harmful effects that derive from artificial substances Americans routinely inject in their foods–and ingest in their bodies.

Is European food better than American? ›

Europeans eat real food products that are healthier, containing more vitamins, minerals and nutrients. Most of what Americans are eating is chemicals, which are adding to obesity.

What are the EU regulations on food? ›

The principal aim of retained EU law Regulation (EC) 178/2002, 'General Food Law' is to protect human health and consumer's interest in relation to food. It applies to all stages of production, processing and distribution of food and feed with some exceptions. Food businesses must comply with food and feed safety law.

Is FDA more strict than Europe? ›

European regulations against additives in food products are stricter than they are in the United States.

Does the EU have higher food standards than the US? ›

European regulations against additives in food products are generally stricter than in the U.S. This difference is due mostly to the fact that Europe has chosen a precautionary approach in regulating, while the U.S. governing bodies tend to be more reactive.

Is Haccp mandatory in Europe? ›

The establishment and implementation of the HACCP system is mandatory for all food producers under Regulation (EC) No 852/2004 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 29 April 2004 on the hygiene of foodstuffs.

Who regulates food safety in Europe? ›

The European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) is the agency of the European Union (EU) that provides independent scientific advice and communicates on existing and emerging risks associated with the food chain.

Is American food safe? ›

American farmers and ranchers are the starting point in our nation's food chain, which produces the safest food supply in the world. The U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) and the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) are home to the primary federal food safety agencies.

Is German food healthier than American? ›

Overall, the foods Germans eat on a daily basis tend to be higher quality and contain less added sugar than their American counterparts. That may explain why despite their love of traditional sweets, Germans consume less sugar than Americans annually.

Why does food taste better in Europe? ›

The difference is that Europeans will often demand and pay for the better quality products due to high standards related to the food they eat. These high standards come with a different cultural expectation and understanding of food. Cooking and food is not a chore, it's part of people's identity.

Is UK food healthier than US? ›

It turns out that British food isn't that terrible, after all. A global survey has found that when it comes to having the healthiest packaged foods and drinks, the UK tops the charts, with the USA in 2nd place and Australia coming in at 3rd. It turns out that British food isn't that terrible, after all.

Which 2 of the following are the main provisions for food hygiene EU regulations? ›

What are the main provision for food hygiene EU regulations?
  • established that primary responsibility for food safety lies with FBOs.
  • laid down that food safety must be protected throughout the food chain, starting with primary production.
  • required the registration of approval of food business establishments.

How many allergens are in EU food regulations? ›

The 14 allergens which must be declared are recognised, across Europe, as the most common ingredients or processing aids causing food allergies and intolerances.

What is Natasha's law? ›

What Is Natasha's Law? The UK Food Information Amendment, also known as Natasha's Law, came into effect on the 1st of October 2021 and requires food businesses to provide full ingredient lists and allergen labelling on foods prepackaged for direct sale on the premises.

What is the difference between US and EU classification? ›

US vs EU – different political structures with common ground

The US is a federal system comprised of 50 states, the District of Columbia and select US territories. By contrast, the EU is a unique economic and political union between 27 European countries.

What is FDA equivalent in Europe? ›

European Medicines Agency (EMA) : EMA is a decentralized body of the European Union, located in Amsterdam in the Netherlands. It is responsible for the scientific evaluation, supervision, and safety monitoring of medicines for human and veterinary use in the EU.

Is EMA stricter than FDA? ›

However, according to a recent study published in the New England Journal of Medicine, the FDA actually approves more drugs, at a faster rate, than the European Medicines Agency (EMA), the equivalent drug approval agency in Europe.

Are US food standards lower than UK? ›

All in all, the food standards of the USA and Australia amongst others, are very much on par than those of the UK

Why is American food so unhealthy compared to other countries? ›

Americans eat more processed food with less fiber, fewer micronutrients, and fewer phytochemicals to protect against heart disease and diabetes.

What food additives are banned in Europe but not US? ›

Most recently, the USDA reported that the European Commission banned the food additive titanium dioxide, although the preservative remains a mainstay in the United States. It's fair to wonder whether there is a reason why additives are banned in Europe but not in the U.S. In short, the answer would be yes.

Is HACCP mandatory in USA? ›

Hazard Analysis Critical Control Point (HACCP) is mandatory by law for manufacturers of meat and poultry, seafood, and juice products . It is otherwise voluntary, provided that the food plant implements a written preventive controls plan according to the Food Safety Modernization Act .

Is HACCP internationally Recognised? ›

What is HACCP? Hazard Analysis and Critical Control Points (HACCP) is the most internationally recognised system based on production of safe food from a preventative approach.

Does FDA apply to Europe? ›

The Europe Office covers the European Union (EU) and individual countries that are not EU members, such as Switzerland and Norway, and facilitates progress on many joint European-U.S. projects spanning the full spectrum of FDA-regulated products.

Which countries have FDA? ›

The agency also has 223 field offices and 13 laboratories located throughout the 50 states, the United States Virgin Islands, and Puerto Rico. In 2008, the FDA began to post employees to foreign countries, including China, India, Costa Rica, Chile, Belgium, and the United Kingdom.
...
Food and Drug Administration.
Agency overview
Websitefda.gov
10 more rows

Why is food safety important EU? ›

It is designed to guarantee safe, nutritious food and animal feed, high standards of animal health and welfare and plant protection, as well as clear information on the origin, content, labelling and use of food.

What foods are banned in other countries but legal in the US? ›

Here are just a few American snacks you won't find in other countries:
  • Mountain Dew & Fresca. Americans who “do the Dew” might be surprised to learn the product contains brominated vegetable oil. ...
  • Little Debbie Swiss Rolls. ...
  • Several Breakfast Cereals. ...
  • Stove Top stuffing. ...
  • Ritz Crackers & Coffee-mate. ...
  • Drumstick frozen desserts.
24 Jul 2022

Is American food regulated? ›

The current food safety laws are enforced by the FDA and FSIS. The FDA regulates all food manufactured in the United States, with the exception of the meat, poultry, and egg products that are regulated by FSIS. The following is a list of all food safety acts, amendments, and laws put into place in the United States.

Is German food healthier than American? ›

Overall, the foods Germans eat on a daily basis tend to be higher quality and contain less added sugar than their American counterparts. That may explain why despite their love of traditional sweets, Germans consume less sugar than Americans annually.

Why is American food so unhealthy compared to other countries? ›

Americans eat more processed food with less fiber, fewer micronutrients, and fewer phytochemicals to protect against heart disease and diabetes.

Why does European food taste better than American? ›

The difference is that Europeans will often demand and pay for the better quality products due to high standards related to the food they eat. These high standards come with a different cultural expectation and understanding of food. Cooking and food is not a chore, it's part of people's identity.

What food additives are banned in Europe but not us? ›

Most recently, the USDA reported that the European Commission banned the food additive titanium dioxide, although the preservative remains a mainstay in the United States. It's fair to wonder whether there is a reason why additives are banned in Europe but not in the U.S. In short, the answer would be yes.

Is food safer in Europe? ›

More than half of consumers agree that food is safe in Europe but there is wide variation from country to country, according to a survey. The EIT Food Trust Report surveyed consumers in different European countries to measure trust in the food system and confidence in food products.

Is UK food healthier than us? ›

It turns out that British food isn't that terrible, after all. A global survey has found that when it comes to having the healthiest packaged foods and drinks, the UK tops the charts, with the USA in 2nd place and Australia coming in at 3rd. It turns out that British food isn't that terrible, after all.

Are people healthier in Europe? ›

American adults reported worse health than did English or European adults. Eighteen percent of Americans reported heart disease, compared with 12% of English and 11% of Europeans. At all wealth levels, Americans were less healthy than were Europeans, but differences were more marked among the poor.

Why is European food so bland? ›

Since Europe doesn't have the same spices available in Asia or Central or South America. If you're more familiar with those spices and the influence as well as the confluence of cultures in cuisine, it's easy to see how you'd think any traditional European food is bland.

Is food less processed in Europe? ›

Generally, countries in southern Europe have lower levels of ultra-processed food in the diet – Portugal at 10.2%, France 14.2%, Italy 13.4% and Greece at 13.7%.

Are Doritos healthier in Europe? ›

When it comes to Doritos, "the U.S. version utilizes three synthetic coloring agents while the U.K. version uses annatto, which is derived from a seed and is a more natural product." Fortunately, there are plenty of healthy snack options that you'll surely find just as tasty.

Why is American produce so bland? ›

The Look and Size of Produce

The growers are not paid for flavor — they are paid for yield. So the breeders have given them this stuff that produces a lot of fruit but that doesn't have any flavor.”

Why does beef in Europe taste different? ›

Several things can make meats taste different. First the diet of the animal. Europe uses less corn and soybean, more rapeseed , wheat,rye and oat. The byproducts available are different too.

Why is everything so sweet in USA? ›

There's added sugar in everything because the government subsidizes the sugar industry. The government subsidizes the sugar industry because it's an important product, both strategically and for international commerce.

Why are Skittles banned in Europe? ›

The ban stems from the use of the color additive titanium dioxide, which food manufacturers in the European Union are now banned from using. It's used in thousands of food products, from chewing gum to salad dressings to coffee creamers and especially in brightly colored candies like Starburst or Skittles.

Why is Gatorade banned in Europe? ›

Gatorade. This sports drink claims to replenish electrolytes, but it also contains food dyes Yellow 5 and Yellow 6. These artificial colors are banned in foods for infants and children in the European Union, and they must also carry warnings on all other products there. They are completely banned in Norway and Austria.

Why are Ritz crackers banned in Europe? ›

Ritz crackers are banned in several countries due to the fact they contain an ingredient called partially hydrogenated cottonseed oil, according to Mashed.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Kelle Weber

Last Updated:

Views: 5450

Rating: 4.2 / 5 (73 voted)

Reviews: 88% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Kelle Weber

Birthday: 2000-08-05

Address: 6796 Juan Square, Markfort, MN 58988

Phone: +8215934114615

Job: Hospitality Director

Hobby: tabletop games, Foreign language learning, Leather crafting, Horseback riding, Swimming, Knapping, Handball

Introduction: My name is Kelle Weber, I am a magnificent, enchanting, fair, joyous, light, determined, joyous person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.